Rookies Cookies is a beloved bakery and cake shop in New Albany, Indiana, known for bringing quality, convenience, and a welcoming shopping experience together in one place.
Located at 310 Pearl St, this neighborhood destination offers customers a reliable spot to satisfy their sweet cravings, pick up treats for special occasions, or simply enjoy a quick stop for something delicious.
Whether you are planning ahead for a celebration or making an impulse visit for a fresh bakery favorite, Rookies Cookies is designed to make every visit easy, pleasant, and rewarding.
What makes Rookies Cookies especially appealing is the flexibility it offers to fit the needs of today’s busy customers. Guests can choose from in-store shopping, in-store pick-up, takeaway, or delivery, making it simple to enjoy quality baked goods in the way that works best for them.
The shop is also ideal for a quick visit, perfect for those who want great service without the wait. Accessibility is thoughtfully supported as well, with a wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance, helping ensure that more customers can comfortably enjoy the experience.
Payments are convenient too, with both credit cards and debit cards accepted for a smooth checkout process.
With a strong customer rating of 4.70 out of 5 from 43 reviews, Rookies Cookies has earned the trust and appreciation of the community through consistent service and a focus on customer satisfaction.
This reputation reflects more than just good baked goods—it speaks to the peace of mind customers feel when they know they can count on friendly service, dependable options, and a place that values both quality and convenience.
For anyone looking for a dependable bakery and cake shop in New Albany, Rookies Cookies offers a warm, accessible, and customer-friendly experience worth returning to again and again.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Rookies Cookies
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
nice place clean and friendly, we purchased sone cookies on a Saturday morning, they are very good, we will be back!
I happened upon this cozy little cookie shop. It was a blessing! I had the most mouthwatering cookies. I will definitely be back!
i ordered a birthday cake for my son and asked to pick up on sunday, they are closed on sunday but she came in that morning to finish and let me pick it up. it smelled so good the whole ride home and every single person I passed, while carrying it into a public venue for the party, said how much they loved it, and so did I!
We had an outdoor/barn wedding and did a small cake for ourselves with cupcakes and cookies for guests, Rookies did great! Arrived on time, everything looked great and was a big hit. Photo cred to Kim Jones Photography.
Went in on Tuesday to have my cake made by Saturday & with it being last minute my daughters 1st birthday cake looked amazing!!! They did exactly what I asked for and it tasted so good. I’m definitely going here for all of my future bakery needs! Highly recommend!!
5/5 would recommend, they did sheet cakes for our wedding and everyone raved about them. Personal favorite is the Italian cream with cream cheese icing, and you could never go wrong with their thumbprint cookies! They matched our wedding colors perfect! Will be back in the future for sure!
10 out of Five 🌟 I stopped in to look/smell and the woman working chatted me up, gave me a sample cookie and then a box of cookies🤯🥰🫶🤗 More proof that New Albany is one of America's great cities🙌
Great cookies! Very friendly service! Definitely worth every penny.
What a wonderful, amazing and delicious experience. I tasked Rookies with a last minute order, that they had no business accepting. Not only did they accept it they made unbelievably awesome volleyball cookies for HHMS 8th grade team!!! This was an awesome ending to the season. Quick!! Great customer service, and some of the best cookies ever according to the team. Thank you Rookies Cookies for your 5 star performance. Buy local!! Will definitely be back.
We got our wedding cake from there!! She went above and beyond for the designed we loved it to so much! It turned out so well and tasted delicious
Common questions about Rookies Cookies
Rookies Cookies is located at 310 Pearl St, New Albany, IN 47150, United States, New Albany, IN, United States.
You can reach Rookies Cookies by calling +1 812-948-8858.
Rookies Cookies has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 based on 43 customer reviews.
Rookies Cookies features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.
Rookies Cookies features the following service options: In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, Takeaway, Delivery.
Rookies Cookies features the following planning: Quick visit.
Rookies Cookies features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
